Doctor Answers: Beta Sitosterol vs Saw Palmetto: What Is The Difference?

If you’re a man concerned about prostate health, you’ve likely come across supplements like beta-sitosterol and saw palmetto. These two plant-based options are often recommended for managing symptoms related to an enlarged prostate, especially benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH). 

To help you understand the differences, effectiveness, and uses of these supplements, we consulted with Dr. Kelepurovski, a medical expert with a deep understanding of men’s health and supplement science. 

Dr. Kelepurovski has reviewed the latest research on beta sitosterol vs saw palmetto and shared insights throughout this article to guide your decisions. All the information provided is based on up-to-date clinical findings and has been reviewed for medical accuracy.

Q: What is Beta-Sitosterol?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: Beta-sitosterol is a plant sterol that’s become increasingly popular among men dealing with prostate issues, particularly BPH. Structurally, it resembles cholesterol and is found in natural foods like seeds, nuts, vegetables, and fruits.Beta-sitosterol reduces urinary symptoms, including frequent urination, incomplete emptying of the bladder and nocturia (waking up at night to urinate). It inhibits the function of 5-alpha-reductase, the enzyme that converts testosterone to dihydrotestosterone (DHT), a hormone associated with enlarged prostate size.

Numerous clinical studies demonstrate evidence that beta-sitosterol improved urinary flow and reduced volume of residual urine, but it does not reduce the size of the prostate. A meta-analysis published in The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews concluded beta-sitosterol was associated with a moderate improvement in urinary symptom and flow measures in men with BPH

Q: What are the main uses of beta-sitosterol?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: Beta-sitosterol is commonly used for two purposes. First, it’s known to help manage cholesterol levels. For instance, a study involving 28 participants with high cholesterol showed that a 12-gram daily dose of phytosterols, including beta-sitosterol, significantly reduced both total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol.

Second, it’s widely used to manage prostate-related symptoms. One review covering four placebo-controlled studies and 519 men found that beta-sitosterol improved urinary flow and reduced other urinary symptoms common with BPH. It’s effective both as a treatment and a preventive supplement.

Q: What is Saw Palmetto?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: Saw palmetto is a fruit-bearing tree with fan-shaped leaves. The ripe fruit is used in supplements aimed at supporting prostate health. The key active ingredient in saw palmetto is beta-sitosterol, though at a much lower concentration compared to a pure beta-sitosterol supplement.

That’s why saw palmetto is often seen as a milder alternative. Additionally, some people use it for hair loss, especially when elevated dihydrotestosterone (DHT) levels are a factor. Saw palmetto may help reduce testosterone’s conversion into DHT, potentially preserving hair and supporting hormone balance.

Some studies have shown a link between dihydrotestosterone and hair loss. By limiting the conversion, there is less of this hormone circulating in the body. Thus, the saw palmetto supplement could prove useful. 

If prostate issues are causing problems with the male reproductive system, then some people may ask about using beta-sitosterol for erectile dysfunction. The effectiveness depends on why the person experiences erectile dysfunction.

Q: How are Beta-Sitosterol and Saw Palmetto Similar or Different?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: Both are used in prostate health supplements, and both contain plant sterols, primarily beta-sitosterol. However, beta-sitosterol supplements are more potent because they contain a concentrated form of the sterol. Saw palmetto contains other sterols too, including campesterol, stigmasterol, brassicasterol, and even some cholesterol.

This broader composition is why some people speculate saw palmetto might help boost circulating testosterone by reducing its conversion into DHT. In contrast, beta-sitosterol supplements are typically more effective at improving urinary symptoms due to their potency.

Similarities: Both supplements are plant-based and used as natural interventions to manage the symptoms of BPH. They may exert effectiveness by inhibiting 5-alpha-reductase, which is the enzyme that converts testosterone to dihydrotestosterone (DHT) that results in prostate enlargement. Both supplements have also been shown to be anti-inflammatory and to potentially relieve symptoms related to BPH like frequent urination, weak urinary stream, and nocturia (nighttime urination).

Differences: As a composition, beta-sitosterol is focused specifically on beta-sitosterol as a single constituent, so this is more specific. Saw palmetto, however, is derived from berries of the plant Serenoa repens, and includes a medley of fatty acids and phytosterols (beta-sitosterol is one phytosterol in saw palmetto but at a lower concentration).

When it comes to clinical evidence, beta-sitosterol performed consistently better. For example, in a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled study published in The Lancet,  beta-sitosterol significantly improved urinary symptoms and flow measures in men with BPH (source). Saw palmetto however has shown mixed results. For example, a large trial published in the New England Journal of Medicine showed that saw palmetto did not confer any significant benefit as compared to placebo on easing BPH symptoms (source).

How Long Does It Take Beta-Sitosterol vs Saw Palmetto To Work?

Conventional medical treatments tend to work relatively quickly. The same is not true even for the best natural prostate supplements. 

When you turn to supplements that use natural ingredients, it is important to note that you have to give it some time to start working. 

There is no fixed time span for when you will notice differences. It generally differs from one person to the next when using prostate supplements that work. You should also ensure you take the appropriate dose daily. 

In most cases, men who use some of the best beta-sitosterol supplements report noticeable improvements within the first three to six months. Due to the low beta-sitosterol content in the alternative, saw palmetto results may take somewhat longer. 

Can I Take Beta-Sitosterol And Saw Palmetto Together?

Many supplements to increase urine flow and improve other prostate symptoms in men use a combination of different ingredients in their formula. 

You may also find that some of these options use both saw palmetto and beta-sitosterol. This brings up the question – can you use beta-sitosterol and saw palmetto in one supplement?

The saw palmetto oil extract in the supplement will contribute to the beta-sitosterol content. This means the supplement will give you a bit more of the plant sterol than what is listed as “beta-sitosterol.” 

It also means that the BPH natural supplements may provide additional benefits, such as helping prevent hair loss, serving as a protector for your prostate, and reducing dihydrotestosterone. 

Q: Which One Is More Effective?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: The effectiveness of beta-sitosterol compared to saw palmetto in the management of benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) symptoms can depend on the particular condition being managed. 

Beta-Sitosterol for Urinary and Prostate Health:

Beta-sitosterol is a plant sterol that has significant efficacy in improving urinary symptoms that arise from BPH. Clinical investigations have shown beta-sitosterol to improve urinary flow rates and reduce residual urine volume. For example, a double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trial published in The Lancet demonstrated beta-sitosterol led to meaningful improvements in urinary symptoms and flow parameters in males with BPH. 

Saw Palmetto for Hormonal Disturbances and Hair Loss:

Saw palmetto is derived from the berries of the Serenoa repens plant, and is often used for its purported inhibitory effect on 5-alpha-reductase, the enzyme responsible for converting testosterone to dihydrotestosterone (DHT). This is significant in that it lends credibility for the treatment of conditions like hair loss (androgenic alopecia) and hormonal disturbances. However, its role in urinary symptoms of BPH is more inconsistent. Saw palmetto has been shown to provide statistically significant improvement in urinary symptoms compared to placebo, but the changes in urinary flow rates were not significant, according to a study published in Urology.

Q: How Long Does It Take for These Supplements to Work?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: Patience is key. As far as natural supplements go with beta-sitosterol and saw palmetto, they do tend to be slow-acting. They work slowly over time by supporting prostate health, affecting the inflammatory state of the prostate, and possibly altering hormone pathways over a longer time course. Most clinical evidence suggests that beta-sitosterol has been found to improve urinary symptoms of BPH after taking it for about 3 to 6 months of consistent use. A well-cited study, published in The Lancet, found that after 6 months of beta-sitosterol supplementing, some men improved with relief of urinary symptoms.

Generally speaking, saw palmetto was found to take longer to affect the prostate, often beyond 6 months, and had more variability of results. While some saw palmetto users report symptom relief, larger reviews, including one in the New England Journal of Medicine, found mixed or limited improvement as compared to placebo (NEJM).

In summary, for either supplement, consistent dose and long enough duration is key. The effects are typically low-level subtle changes that build over time and less dramatic short-term changes. It is an important practice to discuss any supplementation plan with your healthcare provider for safety and appropriateness of other treatment plans.

Q: Can You Take Beta-Sitosterol and Saw Palmetto Together?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: Yes, beta-sitosterol, and saw palmetto are frequently combined into a prostate health product base, and there are some additive effects in using them together. Saw palmetto contains various plant sterols, including beta-sitosterol (in small quantities), as well as fatty acids that may inhibit 5-alpha-reductase, the enzyme that converts testosterone to dihydrotestosterone (DHT). DHT is implicated in urinary symptoms, as well as hormonal hair loss. 

On the other hand, pure beta-sitosterol, at clinically studied doses (usually in the 60-130 mg/day range), has been shown to improve urinary flow and symptoms of BPH more consistently than saw palmetto alone.

So, using both substances together should allow for symptom relief to occur through different mechanisms of action. However, effects would still depend on the dose of each substance, as well as purity of the supplement, and your health status. 

Key FAQs on Beta Sitosterol vs Saw Palmetto

Q: Does beta-sitosterol affect PSA levels (prostate-specific antigen)?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: Recent studies have shown that beta-sitosterol has little or no effect on lowering PSA levels. It is true that beta-sitosterol has been shown to improve urinary symptoms related to benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), but no conclusions on the impact of PSA concentration can be made. 

For example, a randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind clinical trial concluded that beta-sitosterol improves urinary symptoms and flow measures in men with BPH. However, they did not report a decrease in PSA levels. 

Likewise, a systematic review published in the Cochrane Database concluded that beta-sitosterol improved urinary symptoms and flow measures, but did not reduce prostate size or PSA levels compared to placebo.

Q: Can women take saw palmetto or beta-sitosterol for hormonal balance?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: Yes, women can use saw palmetto or beta-sitosterol, especially for hormonal issues—but they should exercise caution and seek medical guidance.

Saw palmetto has anti-androgenic properties and may help lower some excess of dihydrotestosterone (DHT), the hormone associated with conditions such as polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) and female-pattern hair loss. Some studies suggest that saw palmetto could inhibit the enzyme-one responsible for converting testosterone to DHT—therefore it could help with issues of hirsutism, acne, and hair thinning in women.

Beta-sitosterol is common in a lot of plant-based foods and in plant-sourced supplements; it shows some promise in terms of balancing cholesterol levels and potentially hormonal regulation through its anti-inflammatory effect and estrogen-modulating effect. However, clinical evidence for these effects are more limited in women and require further investigation.

Q: Are there any known drug interactions with beta-sitosterol or saw palmetto?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: Yes, both beta-sitosterol and saw palmetto can interact with some prescription medications, but there’s no need to panic—most of these interactions are not serious.

When it comes to saw palmetto:

This supplement might slightly raise the risk of bleeding if you’re also on blood thinners like warfarin, aspirin, or clopidogrel. That’s because saw palmetto can have a mild effect on blood platelets, so one be more cautious when taking anticoagulant therapy.

Saw palmetto could also influence hormone-related medications. If you’re on hormone therapy or birth control pills, it might reduce their effectiveness due to its anti-androgen properties.

As for beta-sitosterol:

This supplement can interact with cholesterol-lowering drugs, particularly ezetimibe, since both aim to reduce cholesterol absorption in the gut. While combining them isn’t necessarily harmful, it could change how well each one works.

Beta-sitosterol might also have additive effects when taken with statins (another type of cholesterol medication), so it’s best to consult your doctor for safe usage.

Q: Is it safe to take beta-sitosterol or saw palmetto long-term without breaks?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers:Current evidence indicates that both saw palmetto and beta-sitosterol are tolerated well for at least 12 to 18 months and can be taken for up to about three years with conventional doses.

Beta-sitosterol – Men who received beta-sitosterol daily for 18 months had ongoing relief of symptoms in a placebo-controlled study, and no serious safety concerns were reported.

Saw palmetto – Saw palmetto was used in clinical trials safely for as long as three years, with only occasional and mild side effects like headaches or stomach discomfort, according to reviews from the U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health.

What to watch for:

Mild side effects like diarrhea and nausea are the most frequent complaints of either supplement.

The occasional report has linked saw palmetto to small, reversible elevations in liver enzymes, so if you already have liver disease, it makes sense to have regular liver-function tests.

Since long-term trials over three years are not common, most medical professionals advise regular follow-ups every 6 to 12 months. It is also beneficial for some users to have short breaks from the supplements once or twice a year, especially if you take other drugs or have bleeding disorders, kidney, or liver illnesses.

Q: How should I choose a high-quality prostate supplement with beta-sitosterol or saw palmetto ingredients?

Dr. Kelepurovski answers: When choosing a prostate supplement containing beta‐sitosterol or saw palmetto, start by making sure that the product uses standardized extracts and includes specific levels. For saw palmetto, look for a Serenoa repens extract that is standardized to 85–95 percent fatty acids and sterols because this concentration was used in most clinical studies. 

For beta-sitosterol, choose a product that specifically states it provides 60–130 mg of clean plant sterols per day, rather than the weight of the oil or raw extract. Second, choose a product that has been third-party tested by a well-regarded firm such as USP, NSF, or ConsumerLab so you can trust that it does contain what’s on the label and is free of common contaminants. 

Avoid products that hide ingredient amounts in “proprietary blends” or include redundant fillers, dyes, or excessive marketing doublespeak like “10 000 mg formula.” 

Finally, purchase from a manufacturer that posts batch test results or Certificates of Analysis (COAs) on the internet, and don’t shy away from phoning up the company if you need clarification. As with any drug, consult with a healthcare professional first—especially if you’re on other medications or have chronic health conditions—to ensure it’s safe and acceptable for you.

Conclusion

Both beta-sitosterol vs saw palmetto offer benefits for men looking to support their prostate health. Beta-sitosterol is more research-backed and potent, especially for improving urinary symptoms. Saw palmetto offers a more holistic blend of sterols and may also help with hair loss and hormone regulation.

If you’re over 40 and want targeted support for prostate issues, a high-quality beta-sitosterol supplement might be your best bet. For broader benefits, including hormonal support, saw palmetto can still play a helpful role, especially when combined with beta-sitosterol.

Our Medical Review Process

At Ben’s Natural Health, we prioritize accuracy, transparency, and scientific integrity. All content is created by qualified healthcare professionals and reviewed every 12 to 24 months to ensure it remains current and evidence-based. We rely exclusively on peer-reviewed studies from reputable medical journals, with full citations and direct links provided to uphold our commitment to credibility and openness. Learn more about our medical review process and research standards.

Our Editorial Guidelines

For over 25 years, Ben’s Natural Health has delivered trusted, science-backed health information. Our rigorous editorial process ensures each article is accurate, reliable, and written to the highest standards. Certified experts—including doctors, dietitians, nutritionists, fitness specialists, and surgeons—create and review all content for medical accuracy. Contributor bios and credentials are displayed at the top of each article for full transparency. Read more about our editorial standards.

Medical Disclaimer

The content on this site is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Although our articles are written and reviewed by licensed healthcare professionals, they may not reflect your specific health needs. Always consult a qualified medical provider for personalized advice. Never ignore or delay seeking medical care based on information from this site. Use of our content is at your own risk.